Notifications
Sign Up Sign In
Q&A

Why "sommaren är kommen" rather than "sommaren har kommit"?

+2
−0

I have seen the phrase sommaren är kommen. What grammatical form is this and how is it correct? I thought it should rather be sommaren har kommit, for summer har arrived (literally: summer has come).

Why should this post be closed?

0 comments

2 answers

+2
−0

I'm a native Swede but not exactly a grammar wizard.

"kommit" is past participle for the verb komma:

  • "komma" = to arrive
  • "kom" = arrived
  • "har kommit" = have arrived

In order to say "I have arrived" in modern Swedish you'd say "jag har kommit". Or more commonly "jag har kommit fram" = "I have arrived (to my intended destination)".

"är kommen" might be passive voice in grammar terms(?), but in everyday use it will sound like an old-fashioned form of "har kommit". "kommen" would be similar to "cometh" in English. So saying "jag är kommen" would sound like "I hast cometh" or similar archaic form. So you wouldn't normally use that form or you'll sound theatrical and very formal.

Versions of "kommen" is mostly used as an adjective, something that has arrived. For example you have "ankommen" (verb and adjective both) which also means "have arrived" but is specifically used when arriving to a travelling destination. Or "hemkommen" meaning arrived home etc.

A phrase "sommaren är kommen" can still be used in modern Swedish when specifically referring to the seasons, though it will sound a bit formal. I'm guessing it's an old saying that has remained. You'll find it in a lot of traditional songs/psalms about spring or summer.

Informally, you'd rather just say "sommaren är här" = summer is here.

1 comment

Thank you for the native insight ‭user53100‭ 29 days ago

+2
−0

"kommen" is the past participle (perfekt particip) of komma. From this site,

Perfekt particip is used as adjective and declines almost the same way as adjectiv. [sic]

An example given in the site of the past participle is "maten är köpt", with a translation being, "the food is bought", and "den köpta maten ligger i kylskåpet" for "the bought food lies in the cupboard".

I'm not a native speaker, but searching for both forms of "summer has come" yields results, suggesting that maybe they are both correct.

2 comments

Is it passive then? This appears to have to do with the difference between supine and past participle. ‭gerrit‭ about 1 month ago

According to the next section of that Wikipedia page, yes, it is the passive voice. @gerrit ‭user53100‭ about 1 month ago

Sign up to answer this question »